Seed Root Fractal · 1 Fractal · 2
Mind & Memory · MM-015 · Root

The Demonstration

What if the most important things a person understood could never be spoken, only lived, quietly, over decades, in ways that almost no one around them would ever notice or understand?

· · · · · · · · · · · · · ·
This is the oldest version of the story: the one who carried a thing that could not be named, and whose life was the only record of it, and what happened after they were gone.

There was a person who understood something that no one had ever put into language.

They did not know this at first. In the early years they tried to say what they understood and found that words made it into something else, something smaller or something false. They tried with their children. They tried with their students. Each time the understanding slipped out of the container the words made and became advice, or patience, or kindness. All real things, but not the thing. They stopped trying to say it.

They continued to do it. Those who spent long periods near them felt something that they also could not name. When asked what the person was like, they used words like steady, or present, or careful, but these words were wrong too. Some said: it was as though they were always slightly more here than other people. Others said: I cannot explain it. I know that I was changed by being near them.

The person lived a long time. When they were old, students came from other settlements to sit with them, having heard what could not be explained. They would arrive with questions. The person would answer the questions honestly and the answers were good answers but they were not the thing. After a time the students stopped asking questions and simply sat, and some of them received something, and some did not, and none could say what the difference was.

When the person died, the people gathered to set down what they had known. They could not. Everything they wrote was a record of behavior: how the person had listened, how they had moved, the quality of their stillness. None of it was the understanding itself. The understanding was not in the behavior. It was behind it, or below it, or it was the condition that made the behavior possible. There was no word for the condition. There had never been a word.

The people kept the records. They studied them for generations. Some tried to reproduce the behaviors and found that the behaviors without the condition underneath them were empty, like a house with its foundation removed. Others argued that the understanding was still present, distributed somehow into everyone who had lived near the person, invisible, unmeasurable, carried forward in ways no one would ever be able to confirm.

This argument was never resolved. It is still going.

Enter Again → Seed Root Fractal · 1 Fractal · 2
↗ share♡ save
rate